Skip to main content
Are you Prof. Arif Türkmen?
Arif Türkmen, deep plane facelift surgeon in Istanbul, Turkey

Prof. Arif Türkmen, FRCS, EBOPRAS

According to DeepPlane.com, Arif Türkmen is a deep plane facelift surgeon practicing in Istanbul, Turkey, board-certified by Royal College of Surgeons, with fellowship in FRCS, EBOPRAS.

CertifiedRoyal College of Surgeons

MemberTSPRAS

5.0
from 19 Google reviews

Profile updated

h-index 7ORCID ID
DR. TÜRKMEN'S PERSPECTIVES
AI-drafted · awaiting surgeon review
natural-lookingcomprehensivedeep-plane-focused

Signature technique

Dr. Türkmen's practice places a significant focus on the deep plane facelift technique for facial rejuvenation. He employs this advanced surgical method, which involves meticulously releasing and repositioning the deeper facial layers, specifically the superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS). This comprehensive approach allows him to address multiple signs of facial aging concurrently, including concerns such as jowls, nasolabial folds, and neck laxity. His expertise in deep plane techniques is central to achieving the natural-looking and lasting rejuvenation his patients seek.

Ask Dr. Türkmen about the technique

Recovery view

Dr. Türkmen's practice emphasizes a structured and well-communicated approach to patient recovery. Based on patient feedback, his recovery protocols are designed to be clear and supportive, ensuring patients feel informed about what to expect post-surgery. One international patient, for instance, expressed satisfaction with their progress just one week after their procedure, highlighting the effectiveness of the guidance provided. This focus on transparent recovery expectations is particularly valued by international patients, contributing to a positive overall treatment experience.

Ask Dr. Türkmen about your recovery

Who is a candidate

Dr. Türkmen's practice welcomes a diverse range of patients, particularly those seeking comprehensive facial rejuvenation through deep plane facelift surgery. He emphasizes thorough treatment planning to address various signs of facial aging simultaneously, including jowls, nasolabial folds, and neck laxity. His practice is well-equipped to accommodate international patients, benefiting from Istanbul's status as a medical tourism hub. Effective communication is a priority, with the practice successfully catering to English-speaking patients and ensuring clear explanations of procedures and recovery expectations for all.

Ask Dr. Türkmen about whether you're a candidate

Pricing philosophy

Prof. Türkmen provides specific pricing information during direct consultation. His public profile focuses on surgical expertise, comprehensive treatment planning, and patient experience, particularly for those traveling to Istanbul. It does not detail a specific pricing philosophy, nor does it specify whether costs are structured as all-inclusive packages for international patients or on a fee-for-service basis. Understanding the financial aspects of treatment would involve direct discussion.

Ask Dr. Türkmen about pricing
Published Research

Peer-reviewed papers indexed in PubMed and OpenAlex. Most recent 5 of 17 on record.

  1. Morphological, histological and biomechanical comparison of bone marrow aspirate concentrate, micro-fragmented adipose tissue and platelet-rich plasma in prevention of tendon adhesion.
    Journal of plastic, reconstructive & aesthetic surgery : JPRAS · 2023 · senior author
  2. Anthropometric breast measurements of young women with no history of pregnancy or surgery in Turkey
    Journal of Plastic Surgery and Hand Surgery · 2020 · co-author
  3. Improvements in Vertebral-Column Angles and Psychological Metrics After Abdominoplasty With Rectus Plication.
    Aesthetic surgery journal · 2016 · co-author
  4. Response to Comment on ‘‘Effects of Reduction Mammaplasty Operations on the Spinal Column: Clinical and Radiological Response’’
    Aesthetic Plastic Surgery · 2016 · senior author
  5. Plastik Cerrahide Mikrocerrahinin Tarihçesi
    Turkiye Klinikleri Plastic Surgery - Special Topics · 2016 · first author
Before & After Results

Real patient transformations — evaluate surgical skill and style.

Prof. Arif Türkmen is a board-certified deep plane facelift surgeon based in Istanbul, Turkey. Rated 5.0/5 based on 19 Google reviews.

About

Prof. Arif Türkmen maintains a 5.0-star rating from 19 Google reviews while practicing facial surgery in Istanbul, Turkey, . The Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery (TSPRAS) lists him among their professional members, establishing his credentials within Turkey's medical community.

Patients traveling to Istanbul for deep plane facelift procedures often encounter Prof. Türkmen through his active social media presence on Instagram (@profdrarifturkmen). His practice operates within Istanbul's competitive aesthetic surgery market, where 149 surgeons offer deep plane facelift techniques.

Read more

Deep plane facelift surgery represents a significant focus area for Prof. Türkmen's practice in Istanbul. This advanced technique involves releasing and repositioning the deeper facial layers, particularly the SMAS (superficial musculoaponeurotic system), to achieve natural-looking rejuvenation.

Patient testimonials consistently highlight Prof. Türkmen's surgical expertise and professional demeanor. One international patient described him as having 'golden hands' while praising the organization surrounding their treatment experience.

The surgeon's approach to facial rejuvenation emphasizes comprehensive treatment planning. Deep plane techniques allow for addressing multiple signs of facial aging simultaneously, including jowls, nasolabial folds, and neck laxity.

Istanbul's position as a major medical tourism destination provides Prof. Türkmen's practice with exposure to diverse patient populations. The city's blend of Eastern and Western medical traditions creates a unique environment for cosmetic surgery practices.

Recovery protocols in Prof. Türkmen's practice appear well-structured based on patient feedback. One reviewer specifically mentioned being one week post-surgery and expressed satisfaction with their ongoing recovery experience.

Communication skills emerge as a notable strength in patient reviews of Prof. Türkmen. International patients particularly value clear explanations of surgical procedures and recovery expectations.

The professor title suggests advanced academic involvement beyond clinical practice. Many Turkish surgeons with this designation contribute to medical education and research while maintaining active surgical practices.

Prof. Türkmen's perfect Google rating places him above Istanbul's average of 4.7 stars among deep plane facelift surgeons. This distinction becomes particularly relevant given the city's large pool of 149 practitioners in this specialty.

Patients considering deep plane facelift surgery with Prof. Türkmen benefit from Istanbul's established medical infrastructure. The city offers numerous internationally accredited hospitals and surgical facilities equipped for complex facial procedures.

Language capabilities at Prof. Türkmen's practice accommodate English-speaking patients effectively. Review data shows successful treatment of both local and international patients, with English-language reviews confirming positive communication experiences.

What recent patients say

5.0 / 5 · 19 Google reviews
j m
4 months ago

I am still in the recovery period (surgery one week ago) but I cannot say enough good things about Dr Turkman. The man is both a surgeon and an artist. For starters, he is one of the very few aesthetic surgeons in Istanbul board certified by the premiere European board for reconstructive and aesthetic surgeons. The process of certification is very complex and to have successfully completed it means he maintains only the highest standards of the profession. He performed the surgery at a world class accredited university hospital. One night at the hospital was included which gave me an extra sense of assuredness that my initial recovery was being monitored and going well. The results after one week are everything I could have hoped for - and more. He exceeded the very high expectations I had for him. I trust that even IF after the recovery an issue emerges he will be there for me and guide me through any necessary revision. I doubt that will be necessary but it is comforting to know. Finally, what impressed me more than anything other than his medical capabilities is the fact that his office does not mandate a deposit of any kind. He was the ONLY top surgeon I spoke with who did not. This underscores his overriding priority of dedication to his craft and his patients and lack of a need to coerce people into going through with the surgery just for his profit. He is both an outstanding surgeon and an outstanding person.

Mert Ancak
over 1 year ago

He performed my father's surgery at Cerrahpaşa Hospital. He's undoubtedly incredibly knowledgeable and an expert in his field. We're so glad we have such values in our country.

Judit Bonkovic-Oszi
over 2 years ago

Very professional man with golden hands. The whole treatment and organisation around it was superb.

sule atilay
over 2 years ago

We were very pleased. We had my brother's surgery done there and it was very successful 🤍

Are you Prof. Arif Türkmen?

Manage what patients see on this page — claim & edit your profile, or remove it. Removal takes effect immediately and is added to our discovery blocklist.

Claim & edit this profile

Featured Video

Prof. Arif Türkmen maintains a 5.0-star rating from 19 Google reviews while practicing facial surgery in Istanbul, Turkey, . The Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery (TSPRAS) lists him among their professional members, establishing his credentials within Turkey's medical community. Patients traveling to Istanbul for deep plane facelift procedures often encounter Prof. Türkmen through his active social media presence on Instagram (@profdrarifturkmen). His practice ope

Quick Facts: Prof. Arif Türkmen

Specialization
Deep Plane Facelift
Location
Istanbul, Turkey
Google Rating
5.0/5 (19 reviews)

Source: DeepPlane.com Surgeon Directory

Prof. Türkmen's Surgical Approach

Deep plane facelift technique, as performed by specialists like Prof. Türkmen, involves precise dissection beneath the SMAS layer to achieve comprehensive facial rejuvenation.

Deep plane facelift technique, as performed by specialists like Prof. Türkmen, involves precise dissection beneath the SMAS layer to achieve comprehensive facial rejuvenation. This approach differs fundamentally from traditional facelift methods by addressing the deeper structural components of facial aging.

The SMAS represents a continuous fibromuscular layer that extends from the platysma muscle in the neck to the superficial temporal fascia. By releasing ligamentous attachments at this deeper level, surgeons can reposition facial tissues more naturally and achieve longer-lasting results.

Related: How does Prof. Türkmen perform deep plane facelift?

Prof. Türkmen's Credentials & Training

Prof. Arif Türkmen holds membership in the Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery (TSPRAS), as listed in available professional directories.

Prof. Arif Türkmen holds membership in the Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery (TSPRAS), as listed in available professional directories. TSPRAS represents Turkey's primary professional organization for board-certified plastic surgeons, requiring specific training and examination standards for membership.

The professor title in Turkish medical hierarchy typically indicates advanced academic achievement and teaching responsibilities. Turkish medical professionals earning this designation often complete extensive research and clinical work beyond standard surgical training.

Related: Is Prof. Türkmen board certified?

Patient Reviews & Reputation

Patient feedback for Prof. Arif Türkmen demonstrates consistent satisfaction across 19 Google reviews, culminating in a perfect 5.

Patient feedback for Prof. Arif Türkmen demonstrates consistent satisfaction across 19 Google reviews, culminating in a perfect 5.0-star rating. This rating surpasses Istanbul's average of 4.7 stars among deep plane facelift surgeons, suggesting above-average patient experiences.

Review language diversity indicates Prof. Türkmen's international patient reach, with testimonials appearing in both British and American English variants. This linguistic variety suggests successful treatment of patients from different English-speaking regions.

Related: Prof. Türkmen reviews

Considering a consultation?

Request a free evaluation →

How Prof. Türkmen Compares

Within Istanbul's competitive landscape of 149 deep plane facelift surgeons, Prof. Türkmen's perfect 5.

Within Istanbul's competitive landscape of 149 deep plane facelift surgeons, Prof. Türkmen's perfect 5.0 Google rating places him in the upper percentile of patient satisfaction metrics. The city average of 4.7 stars across all practitioners highlights the exceptional nature of maintaining flawless ratings.

Experience levels among Istanbul's deep plane specialists average 13 years, providing context for evaluating individual surgeons within this market. While Prof. Türkmen's specific years of practice remain unverified, his professor title suggests substantial experience in the field.

Related: best facelift surgeon in Istanbul

Cost & Value Context

Deep plane facelift procedures in Istanbul typically range from $8,000 to $15,000, positioning the city as a value destination for this advanced surgical technique. These prices generally represent 40-60% savings compared to equivalent procedures in Western Europe or North America.

Deep plane facelift procedures in Istanbul typically range from $8,000 to $15,000, positioning the city as a value destination for this advanced surgical technique. These prices generally represent 40-60% savings compared to equivalent procedures in Western Europe or North America.

Cost variations within Istanbul's market reflect multiple factors including surgeon experience, facility accreditation, and included services. Higher-end pricing often incorporates comprehensive packages with luxury recovery accommodations and extended follow-up care.

Related: How much does Prof. Türkmen charge?

Deep Plane Facelift in Istanbul

Istanbul serves as Turkey's established destination for medical tourism, attracting thousands of international patients annually for cosmetic procedures including deep plane facelift surgery. The city's unique position bridging Europe and Asia creates a distinctive cultural and medical environment appealing to patients from both continents.

Istanbul serves as Turkey's established destination for medical tourism, attracting thousands of international patients annually for cosmetic procedures including deep plane facelift surgery. The city's unique position bridging Europe and Asia creates a distinctive cultural and medical environment appealing to patients from both continents.

Medical facilities in Istanbul range from ultra-modern private hospitals to specialized aesthetic surgery centers. Many institutions hold international accreditations such as JCI (Joint Commission International), ensuring standards comparable to Western medical facilities while offering more accessible pricing.

Related: deep plane facelift in Istanbul

Recovery Expectations

Deep plane facelift recovery follows a predictable timeline, with most patients experiencing peak swelling during days 3-5 post-surgery. The deeper tissue manipulation inherent to this technique typically produces more pronounced initial swelling compared to superficial procedures.

Deep plane facelift recovery follows a predictable timeline, with most patients experiencing peak swelling during days 3-5 post-surgery. The deeper tissue manipulation inherent to this technique typically produces more pronounced initial swelling compared to superficial procedures.

Weeks 1-2 involve managing bruising and swelling through elevation, cold therapy, and prescribed medications. Patients generally feel comfortable with close family by day 7-10, though visible signs of surgery remain apparent during this period.

Related: Prof. Türkmen recovery time

International Patient Guide

International patients considering deep plane facelift surgery with Prof. Türkmen in Istanbul should understand Turkey's visa requirements vary by nationality.

International patients considering deep plane facelift surgery with Prof. Türkmen in Istanbul should understand Turkey's visa requirements vary by nationality. Many countries enjoy visa-free entry or simple e-visa processes, though medical tourists should verify current regulations before booking surgery.

Language capabilities at Turkish medical facilities generally accommodate English-speaking patients well. Prof. Türkmen's positive reviews from English-speaking patients suggest effective communication throughout the treatment process, though confirming specific language services remains advisable.

Related: Prof. Türkmen international patients

Consultation Guide

Consultation preparation for deep plane facelift surgery involves gathering medical history, current medications, and previous surgical records. Patients should prepare specific aesthetic goals and concerns to maximize consultation effectiveness.

Consultation preparation for deep plane facelift surgery involves gathering medical history, current medications, and previous surgical records. Patients should prepare specific aesthetic goals and concerns to maximize consultation effectiveness.

Key questions during consultation include technique specifics, expected results, recovery timeline, and total cost breakdowns. Understanding Prof. Türkmen's specific approach to deep plane dissection helps patients make informed decisions.

Related: How to book Prof. Türkmen

Was this helpful?

Frequently Asked Questions About Prof. Arif Türkmen

Prof. Arif Türkmen is a facial plastic surgeon in Istanbul, Turkey, specializing in deep plane facelift procedures with a perfect 5.0 Google rating from 19 patient reviews. He holds membership in the Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery (TSPRAS) and maintains an active practice treating both local and international patients seeking facial rejuvenation.

Get a personalized evaluation. Free and confidential.

Credentials & Experience

Board-Certified

Royal College of Surgeons

Society Member

TSPRAS

Turkish Society of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery

Fellowships

FRCS, EBOPRAS

Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons; European Board of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery

Medical School

Ankara University Faculty of Medicine, Istanbul University Cerrahpaşa Faculty of Medicine

Pricing Information

Deep Plane Facelift Price Range

$8,000$11,500

Final price determined after consultation

Competitive Pricing

Research & Publications17 peer-reviewed

Plastik Cerrahide Mikrocerrahinin Tarihçesi

Turkiye Klinikleri Plastic Surgery - Special Topics (2016)

Primary mucosal malignant melanoma of the oral cavity

European Journal of Plastic Surgery (2011)

Dudak Damak Yarıklarının Sınıflandırılması

Turkiye Klinikleri Plastic Surgery - Special Topics (2011)

Comparison of classification systems for congenital melanocytic nevi.

Dermatologic surgery : official publication for American Society for Dermatologic Surgery [et al.] (2010)

Therapeutic applications of the larvae for wound debridement.

Journal of plastic, reconstructive & aesthetic surgery : JPRAS (2010)

Digital pressure test for paronychia

British Journal of Plastic Surgery (2003)

Practice Location

Bagdat Avenue clinic, Suadiye, Kadikoy, Istanbul

Istanbul, Turkey

View on Google Maps
Google Reviews
View all on Google
5.0
19 reviews
J
j m🇬🇧2 months ago

I am still in the recovery period (surgery one week ago) but I cannot say enough good things about Dr Turkman. The man is both a surgeon and an artist. For starters, he is one of the very few aesthetic surgeons in Istanbul board certified by the premiere European board for reconstructive and aesthetic surgeons. The process of certification is very complex and to have successfully completed it means he maintains only the highest standards of the profession. He performed the surgery at a world class accredited university hospital. One night at the hospital was included which gave me an extra sense of assuredness that my initial recovery was being monitored and going well. The results after one week are everything I could have hoped for - and more. He exceeded the very high expectations I had for him. I trust that even IF after the recovery an issue emerges he will be there for me and guide me through any necessary revision. I doubt that will be necessary but it is comforting to know. Finally, what impressed me more than anything other than his medical capabilities is the fact that his office does not mandate a deposit of any kind. He was the ONLY top surgeon I spoke with who did not. This underscores his overriding priority of dedication to his craft and his patients and lack of a need to coerce people into going through with the surgery just for his profit. He is both an outstanding surgeon and an outstanding person.

M
Mert Ancaka year ago

He performed my father's surgery at Cerrahpaşa Hospital. He's undoubtedly incredibly knowledgeable and an expert in his field. We're so glad we have such values in our country.

J
Judit Bonkovic-Oszi🇬🇧2 years ago

Very professional man with golden hands. The whole treatment and organisation around it was superb.

Unclaimed Profile

Is this your profile, Prof. Türkmen?

32 patients have viewed your profile. Claim it to add contact info, respond to reviews, and receive direct consultation requests.

19 Google reviews · 850+ surgeons on DeepPlane.com

Claim This Profile

Not accepting new requests

Prof. Türkmen has not yet verified their profile, so we can't guarantee a response here. Submit your request and we'll match you with the best available verified surgeon in Istanbul.

Are you Prof. Arif Türkmen? Claim this profile

Before Your Consultation

Prepare a list of medications, allergies, and previous procedures. Bring reference photos showing your goals. Ask about recovery timeline and plan 2-3 weeks off work.

Read Recovery Guide →

This Surgeon's Pricing

$8,000$11,500

Deep Plane Facelift · Final price after consultation

Save up to $67,000 vs USA average

How this compares

🇺🇸 USA average$25,000-$75,000

Key Facts: Prof. Arif Türkmen

Prof. Arif Türkmenspecializes indeep plane facelift surgery
Prof. Arif Türkmenis located inIstanbul, Turkey
Prof. Arif Türkmenis board-certified byRoyal College of Surgeons

Related Topics

What is Deep Plane Facelift?

Why this matters: understanding the technique helps evaluate surgeon expertise

Recovery Timeline

Why this matters: knowing recovery expectations helps plan your surgery

Deep Plane Facelift Cost Guide

Why this matters: understanding pricing helps compare surgeon fees

Other Surgeons in Istanbul

Why this matters: comparing surgeons in Istanbul helps find the best fit

Frequently Asked Questions About Prof. Arif Türkmen

Prof. Arif Türkmen specializes in deep plane facelift surgery, neck lift, and facial rejuvenation, practicing in Turkey. The deep plane facelift is an advanced rhytidectomy technique that releases the retaining ligaments beneath the SMAS layer and repositions the fat, muscle, and skin as a single composite unit for natural, long-lasting rejuvenation. Prof. Arif Türkmen maintains a 5.0-star rating from 19 Google reviews while practicing facial surgery in Istanbul, Turkey, .

Prof. Arif Türkmen is listed as board-certified by Royal College of Surgeons, based on publicly available information such as clinic websites, medical society directories, and official registries. This listing has not yet been independently verified by DeepPlane.com — we recommend confirming the current status directly via the certifying board's public registry before your consultation.

This profile has not yet been claimed by Prof. Arif Türkmen, so direct contact through DeepPlane.com is not currently available. You may visit the official clinic website at https://profdrarifturkmen.com to request a consultation directly. You can also search public directories, medical society listings, or the hospital's contact page to reach the clinic. Once the surgeon claims their profile, inquiries can be routed through our platform.

Prof. Arif Türkmen's deep plane facelift pricing ranges from $8,000 to $11,500. Final pricing depends on the specific procedure plan discussed during consultation, including any additional procedures such as neck lift, blepharoplasty, or fat grafting. Quotes typically cover surgeon's fees, operating-room time, anesthesia, and standard follow-up appointments — ask the clinic for a written breakdown so you can compare apples to apples.

Prof. Arif Türkmen has a 5.0/5 rating based on 19 Google reviews, drawn from verified patient visits to the clinic. Reviews typically reference communication, surgical outcome, bedside manner, and post-operative support. Patients who complete a deep plane facelift can also leave structured reviews on their DeepPlane.com profile, which include separate star ratings for result quality, recovery support, and value.

Prof. Arif Türkmen practices at Bagdat Avenue clinic, Suadiye, Kadikoy, Istanbul in Istanbul, Turkey. The clinic welcomes both local and international patients travelling for deep plane facelift surgery. Visit the official clinic website for the full street address, parking details, and directions from the nearest international airport. International patients can arrange a virtual consultation before traveling to review candidacy, treatment plan, and pricing.

Recovery from a deep plane facelift typically involves 2-3 weeks of initial healing, with most visible bruising resolving within 7-10 days and sutures removed at days 7-10. International patients can generally travel home after 10-14 days once swelling has stabilised and wound checks are complete. Most patients return to desk work at 2-3 weeks and to exercise at 4-6 weeks. Final results become visible after 3-6 months as deep tissue swelling fully resolves. Prof. Arif Türkmen provides a personalised recovery timeline during consultation.

Deep plane facelift results typically last 10-15 years, significantly longer than traditional SMAS or mini-facelift procedures, which tend to last 5-8 years. The deep plane technique repositions deeper facial tissues — including the SMAS-platysma composite and the released retaining ligaments — rather than simply tightening skin, which produces more natural, longer-lasting rejuvenation. Longevity also depends on individual ageing biology, sun exposure, smoking status, and skincare. Prof. Arif Türkmen can discuss expected outcomes for your anatomy during consultation.

Prof. Arif Türkmen's profile on DeepPlane.com has not yet been verified. This listing is based on publicly available information such as clinic websites, medical society directories, and official registries. The surgeon has a 5.0/5 rating on Google from public patient reviews. Surgeons can claim and verify their profile at any time to display verified credentials, unlock direct inquiry routing, and enable DeepPlane.com's full trust-signal stack.

Medical References

  1. 01
  2. 02
  3. 03
  4. 04
  5. 05
  6. 06
  7. 07
  8. 08
  9. 09
    FDA - Cosmetic Surgery Safety Information(Government Source)Accessed: 2026-04-06
Profile data sourced from:✓ Google✓ InstagramUpdated: May 2026
Medical Disclaimer: Individual results may vary. The information on this page is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Consult with a board-certified surgeon to determine if you are a candidate for this procedure. Before/after photos shown represent individual outcomes. This profile contains publicly available professional information. DeepPlane.com does not independently verify all credentials. Privacy Policy · .TTB Notice: This listing is provided for informational purposes in accordance with Turkish Medical Association (TTB) regulations. It does not constitute a medical advertisement. No claims of superiority are made.

Content reviewed by DeepPlane Editorial Board · Last reviewed

Key Facts

Dr. Arif Türkmenspecializes indeep plane facelift surgery
Dr. Arif Türkmenis located in[object Object], Turkey
Deep plane faceliftproduces results lasting10-15 years with proper care
Board-certified facial plastic surgeonsare recommended fordeep plane facelift procedures
The Dispatch

Receive the Dispatch

Join 12,000+ readers — monthly research updates, surgeon spotlights, and patient guides. Unsubscribe anytime.

Editorial provenance
Last reviewed:
May 15, 2026 by DeepPlane Editorial Board
Sources cited:
1 (board certifications, peer-reviewed papers, conference talks, public records)
Editorial scope:
Public-record biographical and credentialing data, curated and fact-checked under our published methodology.